Scotch Collie vs Broholmer - Breed Comparison | MyDogBreeds

Scotch Collie vs Broholmer - Breed ComparisonScotch Collie is originated from United Kingdom but Broholmer is originated from Denmark. Scotch Collie may grow 14 cm / 5 inches shorter than Broholmer. Scotch Collie may weigh 48 kg / 105 pounds lesser than Broholmer. Scotch Collie may live 4 years more than Broholmer. Both Scotch Collie and Broholmer has almost same litter size. Both Scotch Collie and Broholmer requires Moderate maintenance.

History

scotch collie - historyThe landrace breed, which started in the highlands of Scotland is known as the Scotch Collie. There were at the time two types of collies – the Rough or long haired collie and the smooth or short haired collie. The Scotch Collie is considered to be from a line of very ancient herding dogs. It might have existed in the days of the Roman Empire, these herding dogs might have included the Native Celtic Dogs, Roman Cattle Dogs, Gordon Setter, Viking Herding Spitzes and Irish Setters.

In its native land the Scotch Collie is often called the colley dogs, coaly and cooley. Collie comes from the Scottish words for black coal – or the Coaley Sheep they herded. In addition to herding, the Scotch Collie also acted as a hunter and guard dog for its family. A large group of these collies were exported to America to work on family farms. Soon they were so popular they became family pets. They were first shown in both England and America in in the mid to late 1800’s.

The Scotch Collie Club was formed in 1885 and the breed accepted into the AKC the same year. The Collie Club of America started the following year. The AKC eventually dropped the moniker Scotch in favor or Rough and Smooth Collie. This move also separated the show dogs from the still working/herding Scotch Collies.

Aa time went on and the collie became more prominent in conformation competitions, some breeders mixed in the Greyhound and perhaps the Borzoi to get the collie we see today. The Scotch Collie itself eventually lost its independent recognition in the UKC and the NKC. It was mixed in with the English Shepard, but it was an important element in the development of the Australian Shepard, Shetland Sheepdogs and Border Collies.

The breed had a revival of sorts in the early 2000’s as the Old Time Scotch Collie. Any type of farm collie in America and Canada can be registered in the OTSCA. They are more often referred to as Old Time Farm Shepherds to avoid confusion them with the very popular collies. In 2017 there were 174 of these OTSCA dogs. Collies today have less working instincts, and the heeling instinct seems to be gone.

Today the show version of the Scotch Collie is recognized by both the AKC and UKC in the herding group.

It has been said of the Scotch Collie that they have “the majesty of a lion, the pride of a great thoroughbred stallion, the confidence of a Winston Churchill.”

broholmer - historyThis giant dog, the Broholmer, comes from Denmark and falls into the general Molosser type of Mastiff dog. The breed was originally developed by crossing the local German dogs with the English Mastiffs to create what is also known as a Danish Mastiff. The breed is named after an 18th century game-keeper names Sehested of Broholm. This type of dog has been present however since the Middle Ages in Europe. It started out as a stag hunting dog but quickly evolved into a guard dog. They were greatly favored by the wealthy and nobility, including being featured in portraits with King Frederick VII and Countess Danner.

Like many European dogs, the Broholmer, did not fare well during the second World War. During this time there was little purebred breeding and their numbers decreased almost to the point of extinction. Brought back by a group called “The Society for the Reconstruction of the Broholmer Breed”. With the support of the Danish Kennel Club, they were successful in bring the breed back. They were recognized by both the Federation Cynoloqique Internationale and the Danish Kennel Club. By 2009 they were being imported to the United Kingdom, hoping to get them onto the import lists of the United Kingdom kennel club (UKC).

Basic Information

Group:
Herding dogs
Molosser dogs
Origin:
United Kingdom
Denmark
Height Male:
53 - 61 cm
20 - 25 inches
70 - 75 cm
27 - 30 inches
Height Female:
47 - 56 cm
18 - 23 inches
68 - 77 cm
26 - 31 inches
Weight Male:
21 - 32 kg
46 - 71 pounds
40 - 80 kg
88 - 177 pounds
Weight Female:
18 - 27 kg
39 - 60 pounds
37 - 77 kg
81 - 170 pounds
Life Span:
12 - 16 Years
7 - 12 Years
Litter Size:
2 - 8
4 - 10
Size:
Medium dog
Giant dog
Other Names:
Farm Collie • Old Farm Collie
Danish Broholmer • Danish Mastiff
Colors Available:
All colors and markings traditionally found on collies
light or brownish yellow, or black
Coat:
double top harsh under soft
harsh short
Shedding:
Moderate
Seasonal
Temperament:
Energetic, Independent, Intelligent, Responsive
Affectionate, Friendly, Gentle, Intelligent, Loving, Loyal, Protective, Stubborn
Grooming:
Moderate maintenance
Moderate maintenance
Trainability:
Easy
Easy
Hypoallergenic:
No
No
Kids Friendly:
Yes
Yes
New Owners Friendly:
Yes
Yes

Description

scotch collie puppy - descriptionThis Scotch Collie is an athletic, intelligent, well-balanced and alert dog. This collie has no exaggerated features like the long nose/muzzle of the current collies. This Scotch Collie is sound in mind and body, a hard working dog. He is hearty and versatile. They are longer than they are tall. Their heads are moderate and the stoop is well defined. They have a wide, flat skull. Their lips are tight and they are fitted well.

Their ears are also moderate in size and pointed or partially erect. They should not have long or droopy ears. They have eyes that might be oblique, almond, and round. The eyes are usually brown and merles may have blue eyes. The breed has a deep chest, broad shoulders and a long tail. There are also some bobtails that occur naturally.

broholmer puppy - descriptionThe Broholmer is a very large dog with Mastiff qualities. He is strong, rectangular and powerful in build. He has a massive head and neck with a deep and broad chest. The length of the nose is the same as the length of the skull. He is tall, well built and his thing and hindquarters are powerful. His stance and gait are powerful and intimidating as well. His appearance and size alone account for his guard dog status. However, he is a little smaller than most Mastiffs and he is athletic looking as well.

The Broholmer is a double coated breed with a short topcoat and a thick undercoat. The color of the Broholmer is yellow or a golden red. Some have white on the feet, tail tip or chest and some have a black mask. Most do not have any mask.

Characteristics

1.Children friendliness - they are great with children.

2.Special talents agility and speed.

scotch collie dog - characteristics3.Adaptability - Scotch Collies are versatile and adaptable. There is no need to crate them as they are not destructive. If you have a large run or kennel, they can live anywhere. However they are happiest on farms and open lands.

4.Learning ability - They are very intelligent and open to learning.

broholmer dog - characteristicsThe Broholmer is a calm, friendly dog. He is a large dog that thinks he is a lap dog. He wants to be close and snuggle with his people all the time. He is great with kids and other dogs. At the same time, he can be very watchful and protective. Because of this along with his size he needs a strong owner who is clearly the pack leader. He is wary and protective around strangers and can be stubborn if he thinks he is in charge.

Health Problems

scotch collie puppies - health problemsThe old line breed was hearty with few health issues. The ones they did have included:

  • Musculoskeletal problems - can cause weakness or even some lameness.

• Skin problems - can have skin diseases like mange that may or may not be acute, may have allergies or sensitivities.

  • Bloat – can cause death if not treated quickly.

broholmer puppies - health problemsThe Broholmer faces many of the same health issues as other large breeds, even though he is overall a very healthy breed. Some of the types of health issues the Broholmer might deal with include:

Bloat – caused by eating a large meal too quickly and drinking a lot of water or exercising too soon before or after the large meal.

Hip and Elbow Dysplasia – When the bones do not fit well into the joints.

Eye Issues – Entropion, Ectropium, Cataracts and PRA

Cardiac Issues

Back Issues

Caring The Pet

scotch collie dogs - caring1Feeding the puppy - The Scotch Collie is not a medium dog nor is it a large dog. It is somewhere in-between. Because of this there is some discretion in not only how much you feed your puppy, but also what you feed. Normally we would feed according to breed size but here you need a high quality formula that is made for working breeds. The puppy will need enough calories to meet their high energy needs. Feed at least 3-4 times a day.

2.Feeding the adult - you need a high quality formula that is made for working breeds. The adult will need enough calories to meet their high energy needs. Feed at least 2 times a day.

3.Points for Good Health - stamina and athleticism.

4. Games and Exercises

There is a high need for exercise starting with walks or jog but that is not going to be enough. The Scotch Collie is not a Border Collie or a Corgi in terms of energy, but they are not couch potaoes. They need more than access to a yard. They need a job or they need defined exercise and play. The daily walk or jog will do it but intense play is better.

Feeding

broholmer dogs - caringDon’t overfeed the Broholmer. Give her about three and three quarters to nine cups of a high quality dry food. Depending on the size of your dog, adjust the amount of food within the guidelines listed here. Feed at least twice a day. Use a large breed dog food.

Health issues

Bloat – when the stomach is twisted and distended. This can cause death is not responded to by a vet immediately.

Hip and Elbow Dysplasia – causes lameness and arthritis.

Eye Issues – Entropion turning inward of eyelids and irritating eye; Ectropium eyelids turn outward, Cataracts and Progressive Retinal Atrophy (PRA) -genetic defects of the retina can cause blindness.

Cardiac Issues – can cause weakness or death

Back Issues – can cause disc issues

Exercise and Games

The Broholmer is not an overly active dog but he is big and athletic so has strong exercise needs. A large fenced in back yard is essential or be prepared for several long walks every day. You can play inside games like teaching new tricks or hide and seek but remember this is a big dog. He would love to swim, play frisbee or ball, go hiking or organized activities such as fly ball, agility, rally and obedience. Don’t let your Broholmer over exercise while it is young and still growing. He needs as much mental stimulation as physical exercise.

Comparison with other breeds

  1. English Mastiff vs Broholmer - Breed Comparison
  2. Neapolitan Mastiff vs Broholmer - Breed Comparison
  3. Gaddi Kutta vs Broholmer - Breed Comparison
  4. Nebolish Mastiff vs Broholmer - Breed Comparison
  5. Broholmer vs American Mastiff - Breed Comparison
  6. Broholmer vs American Molossus - Breed Comparison
  7. Broholmer vs Cao de Gado Transmontano - Breed Comparison
  8. Great Dane vs Broholmer - Breed Comparison
  9. Newfoundland Dog vs Broholmer - Breed Comparison
  10. Leonberger vs Broholmer - Breed Comparison
  11. Irish Wolfhound vs Broholmer - Breed Comparison
  12. Francais Blanc et Orange vs Broholmer - Breed Comparison
  13. Mountain Burmese vs Broholmer - Breed Comparison
  14. Pyrenean Mastiff vs Broholmer - Breed Comparison
  15. Moscow Watchdog vs Broholmer - Breed Comparison
  16. Scottish Deerhound vs Broholmer - Breed Comparison
  17. Shiloh Shepherd vs Broholmer - Breed Comparison
  18. Irish Mastiff Hound vs Broholmer - Breed Comparison
  19. Spanish Mastiff vs Broholmer - Breed Comparison
  20. St. Bernard vs Broholmer - Breed Comparison
  21. Kars Dog vs Broholmer - Breed Comparison
  22. Scotch Collie vs Pembroke Welsh Corgi - Breed Comparison
  23. Scotch Collie vs Australian Shepherd - Breed Comparison
  24. Scotch Collie vs Belgian Shepherd Dog (Malinois) - Breed Comparison
  25. Scotch Collie vs Australian Cattle Dog - Breed Comparison
  26. Scotch Collie vs Bearded Collie - Breed Comparison
  27. Scotch Collie vs Collie - Breed Comparison
  28. Scotch Collie vs Austrailian Blue Heeler - Breed Comparison
  29. Scotch Collie vs Dutch Shepherd - Breed Comparison
  30. Scotch Collie vs Blue Healer - Breed Comparison
  31. Scotch Collie vs English Shepherd - Breed Comparison
  32. Scotch Collie vs Australian Collie - Breed Comparison
  33. Scotch Collie vs Catahoula Cur - Breed Comparison
  34. Scotch Collie vs Australian Red Heeler - Breed Comparison
  35. Scotch Collie vs Catalan Sheepdog - Breed Comparison
  36. Scotch Collie vs Pyrenean Shepherd - Breed Comparison
  37. Scotch Collie vs Bergamasco - Breed Comparison
  38. Scotch Collie vs Berger Picard - Breed Comparison
  39. Scotch Collie vs Appenzell Mountain Dog - Breed Comparison
  40. Scotch Collie vs Queensland Heeler - Breed Comparison
  41. Scotch Collie vs German Coolie - Breed Comparison
  42. Scotch Collie vs Bohemian Shepherd - Breed Comparison
  43. Scotch Collie vs Croatian Sheepdog - Breed Comparison
  44. Scotch Collie vs Red Heeler - Breed Comparison
  45. Scotch Collie vs Belgian Shepherd Dog (Tervuren) - Breed Comparison
  46. Scotch Collie vs Blue Lacy - Breed Comparison

View/Compare Breeds

Popular Dog Breeds